Guide · 7 min read · Updated 2026

What Type of Mortar Is Best for Old Brick Homes?

The wrong mortar can destroy good brick in a single decade. For older Boston-area homes, choosing mortar is more important than choosing a contractor's color sample.

The mortar types, simplified

ASTM C270 defines mortar by strength, from hardest to softest: M, S, N, O, and K. Older brick was typically laid in lime mortar, which is softer than any of these.

  • Type M/S: high strength, used for below-grade and structural new work
  • Type N: general-purpose, suitable for many post-1930 homes
  • Type O: softer, good for many older, exposed brick walls
  • Lime / Type K: historic and very soft brick

Why softer is often better

Mortar should be the sacrificial element. When it's softer than brick, movement and moisture pass through the joints. When it's harder, the brick edges crack and faces spall.

Mortar analysis

For historic buildings, a lab or field analysis of the original mortar identifies binder and sand so the new mix matches in performance and appearance, as recommended by NPS Preservation Brief 2.

Frequently asked questions

Is Type S mortar bad for old brick?

Often, yes. Type S is usually too hard for soft pre-1930 brick.

What is natural hydraulic lime (NHL)?

A lime binder that sets partly by reacting with water, giving lime-like breathability with better early strength.

Does mortar color matter?

Yes, for appearance. Color comes mostly from sand; pigments fine-tune the match.

Call Now — 781-818-1668